Monday, July 16, 2007 Reeves: Privileges and consequences of voluntary departure By Robert L. Reeves
ALTHOUGH voluntary departure is considered a privilege, all too often aliens accept this privilege without fully realizing the benefits and possible consequences.
If you are really planning to leave the United States, voluntary departure may be an appropriate option. However, if you are using the voluntary departure time for delay, hoping that visa will become available, you can be taking much too great a risk. Perhaps the most important question to ask yourself when you consider voluntary departure is whether you are truly going to leave the United States.
What is voluntary departure and how does one obtain it?
An alien in removal proceedings may request voluntary departure at either the outset of the removal hearing or at the end of the removal hearing. If the alien requests voluntary departure at the outset of the hearing, then the immigration judge may grant an alien a maximum of 120 days to voluntarily depart the United States.
The immigration judge may also prescribe certain conditions before granting voluntary departure such as setting a bond. An alien who seeks voluntary departure at this stage may not request any other form of relief, must concede removability and must waive their right to appeal the decision. This option is only recommended after a careful review of the case and should be reserved for aliens who have no other forms of relief and have decided that they are truly going to leave the United States.
An alien may also request voluntary departure at the conclusion of the removal hearing as a form of alternative relief. At this stage, an immigration judge may grant a maximum of 60 days to voluntarily depart the United States if the alien can demonstrate that they have been physically present in the United States for at least one year, they posses good moral character, they are not an aggravated felon, they have the means to depart the United States and intend to do so, and they post a $500 bond.
If the alien accepts voluntary departure at this stage, the period may be tolled during any appeal process. An alien should not accept voluntary departure at this stage unless they fully understand the need to comply with all the requirements —most importantly the requirement to leave the United States within the voluntary departure time period.
What if one accepts voluntary department but does not leave?
Realizing that many aliens would accept voluntary departure and simply remain in the United States, Congress enacted a law to impose harsh consequences for failing to leave the United States. Specifically, if an alien fails to timely depart he can be fined up to $5,000 and would become ineligible for 10 years to avail himself of many forms of immigration benefits.
Chief among the lost benefits is the ability to apply for adjustment of status (obtain a green card.) So, even if an alien has an approved visa petition, no criminal record, and no record of any fraud, he would be barred for a period of 10 years from receiving a green card.
The 10-year period begins from the date the alien was required to have departed the United States.
Furthermore, the Board of Immigration Appeals has held that an alien is barred from filing a motion to reopen to apply for adjustment of status if he failed to depart the United States. This is commonly known as a “Shaar Bar,” named for the Board’s case law in Matter of Shaar.
It is important to note, however, that if an alien has remained in the United States longer than the 10-year bar, then it might be possible to file a motion to reopen if the alien is other eligible to apply for adjustment of status.
When can one return to the US after leaving voluntarily?
Perhaps no aspect of voluntary departure is more misunderstood than its effect on an immigrant’s eligibility to return to the US. Although accepting voluntary departure avoids the consequences of a removal order (a 10 year bar from returning to the United States), many immigrants still face other grounds of inadmissibility when they seek to reunite with their families.
A common ground of inadmissibility that is not solved by voluntary departure is the 10-year bar for unlawful presence. For example, an immigrant who was unlawfully present in the US for over one year and voluntarily departs still faces a 10-year bar from returning to the US.
Although the immigrant would not need to waive any bar resulting from a removal order, he will need to file a waiver for the unlawful presence bar.
Because the consequences of failing to depart are so severe, and the benefits of returning are so limited, the privilege of voluntary departure is not for everyone.
Instead of gambling with your life and choosing voluntary departure as a quick and risky solution, an immigrant should first consult an attorney experienced in immigration matters to carefully evaluate his or her case and see if voluntary departure would be best.
