Police say 2 men mauled fellow detainee

MANILA. Genesis Argoncillo complained of difficulty breathing while in detention at the Novaliches Police Station. He died shortly after he was brought to the hospital. (Contributed photo)

THE Quezon City Police District (QCPD) identified on Friday, June 22, the two men who allegedly mauled and caused the death of fellow detainee Genesis “Tisoy” Argoncillo.

Argoncillo’s death has prompted the relief of five police personnel including the commander of the Novaliches Police Station, Superintendent Carlito Grijaldo, and Police Officer 3 Dennis Sano, who was supposed to be guarding the detention facility at the Novaliches Station, pending the investigation.

Critics have blamed the incident on the police’s anti-tambay operations, since Argoncillo was initially reported to have been arrested on June 15 for loitering shirtless. Police have insisted that he was arrested for alarms and scandals.

QCPD director Joselito Esquivel said based on the statement of three witnesses, detainees Richard Bautista and Justin Mercado beat up Argoncillo at around 10 p.m. of Monday, June 18, inside the detention facility of the QCPD Police Station (PS) 4 in Novaliches.

The witnesses said the two suspects are members of the Sputnik gang. Both the witnesses and suspects were detainees at the Novaliches Station at the time of the incident.

QCPD Crime Investigation and Detection Unit (CIDU) chief Rodel Marcelo said based on the accounts of the witnesses, Argoncillo was restless on the night of June 18 and might have stepped on fellow detainees who were sleeping on the floor of the facility.

“Malinaw sa testimonya noong isang testigo na allegedly itong si Tisoy uneasy palakad-lakad, tumatakbo sa loob ng kulungan may time na naapakan ‘yung ibang presong natutulog. ‘Yun ang nagignite doon sa dalawa (Bautista and Mercado) nung bawalan hindi nagpa-bawal ‘yun na doon na binugbog nung gabi nung (June) 18 ‘yun at nung (June) 19 dumaing na ng paghirap sa paghinga,” he said.

Esquivel said they are looking into the involvement of other inmates in Argoncillo’s mauling as the witnesses said that several other inmates shielded the beating of Argoncillo so as not to attract the attention of the police officer on duty.

Esquivel assured there was no gang war inside the detention facility. He said the witnesses are not members of either Sputnik or Bahala Na gangs. One has been released on bail while the two other witnesses were transferred to the custody of the CIDU to ensure their safety.

Conflicting statements

Esquivel earlier denied that Argoncillo was tortured, as alleged by the family.

He said the young man died as a result of the congestion at the detention facility. He also quoted Argoncillo’s attending physician, Jethiel Fabon, as saying there were no external injuries on Argoncillo’s body.

During Friday’s press conference, Esquivel admitted that Argoncillo was beaten up, not by the police but by the two suspects.

Esquivel said they were not trying to cover up the cause of Argoncillo’s death. He said he based his earlier statements on the report provided by his men.

“Initially pag nag-conduct ang physician declaring the death of a person cursory examination lang ‘yun...there are two kinds of wounds the internal and external at the onset it was reported that there were no signs of external injuries but during the more in depth examination such as the autopsy it revealed that he died of multiple blunt force trauma in the neck, head, chest and upper extremities,” said Esquivel.

“We are not changing the tune of our press release, we stand by the fact that at the time of the death the report was that there was no reported external injuries and we did not stop... we investigated and we come to a conclusion last night that there was indeed beating up that led to the death of Tisoy,” he added.

Esquivel maintained that Argoncillo was arrested due to alarm and scandal. He denied the family’s allegation that Argoncillo was arrested for loitering on the street shirtless during the police’s anti-tambay operation.

He said Argoncillo was arrested around 8 p.m. of June 15 after police received reports that he was challenging people in their area to a fight.

Esquivel said the QCPD’s anti-tambay operations usually start at around 10 p.m. based on the curfew hours.

As reported, Barangay Sauyo deputy barangay public safety officer said based on their record, Argoncillo was arrested along with six other persons around 9:30 p.m. during the conduct of police Oplan Galugad for being shirtless.

One of the family’s neighbors who witnessed the arrest also belied the police claim that Argoncillo was causing trouble in their area prior to his arrest.

“Si Tisoy ay ang bihira bumaba ng bahay yon. Wala hindi siya nagiingay nun, natiyempuhan lang na nakahubad siya nun,” said Alfonso Ascura.

Family’s doubts

During the said press conference, Marilou, Agoncillo’s sister refused to believe that the police was never involved in the mauling of her brother and that it was only perpetrated by the other inmates.

“Hindi po kasi nung una palang nung umaga nung naghatid ako sa kapatid ko ang sabi nung nagtanong ako kasi wala doon sa loob ang kapatid ko nagtanong ako sabi nilabas daw nila ang kapatid ko tapos ilipat daw sa station 2 tapos nagwala daw ang kapatid ko sa labas dahil ayaw magpalipat. Pero ang sinasabi sakin ng kapatid ko gustong-gusto niya na magpalipat nung umpisa pa lang walang tulog walang pahinga ang kapatid ko,” she said when asked if she believed the police.

“Tapos ginawan pa nila ng (kwento) ang kapatid ko na hinampas hampas ang ulo sa ano ang ibig sabihin may ano rin silang mga pulis kasi sa labas nangyari nilabas nila ang kapatid ko dahil ililipat,” she added.

She also maintained that her brother was arrested not over alarm and scandal but for loitering on the street without a shirt.

Esquivel said the police will continue to investigate to identify the possible liability of the officers on duty as well as the identification of the other inmates involved in the killing. (SunStar Philippines)


SunStar website welcomes friendly debate, but comments posted on this site do not necessarily reflect the views of the SunStar management and its affiliates. SunStar reserves the right to delete, reproduce or modify comments posted here without notice. Posts that are inappropriate will automatically be deleted.

Forum rules:

Do not use obscenity. Some words have been banned. Stick to the topic. Do not veer away from the discussion. Be coherent. Do not shout or use CAPITAL LETTERS!