Namfrel says 1 M votes still not transmitted

CEBU. Voting for the midterm National and Local Elections ended at 6 p.m., Monday, May 13. About 40 hours later, nearly 2,000 election returns still have to be transmitted through the Comelec Transparency Server, according to the election watchdog Namfrel. (Photo by SunStar Cebu)

NEARLY 2,000 election returns (ER) with about a million votes, assuming a 75 percent voter turnout, have not been transmitted through the Comelec Transparency Server as of Wednesday morning, May 15.

Election watchdog National Citizens' Movement for Free Elections (Namfrel) said the unaccounted number of votes is large enough to reorder the positions in the senatorial race, especially the 10th to 14th ranks.

As of 10:16 a.m. Wednesday, Namfrel said in a statement that the results in the partial and unofficial senatorial count in the Commission on Elections (Comelec) Transparency Server covered 97.75 percent or 83,842 of the local ERs from across the country.

This means 2.25 percent of 85,769 local ERs are not yet included in the count.

"The delay in the transmission of ERs could be due to vote-counting machine (VCM) malfunction, Secure Digital (SD) card issues, transmission issues, or other factors," Namfrel said.

"Comelec municipal and provincial election officers should exert all efforts to transmit unreported ERs to reduce the 2.25 percent untransmitted ERs because the numbers are critical in the senatorial contest where the figures among those in Numbers 10 to 14 positions are very close," the watchdog added.

The figure, 2.25 percent of 85,769, is equivalent to 1,930 untransmitted local ERs and 1,043,721 votes, assuming a 75 percent turnout of voters.

The margin of votes between the current 10th to the 14th placers now stands at 398,000, well within the 1,043,721 unaccounted votes.

Explaining how the 1,043,221 votes was derived, Namfrel said it divided the Total Number of Voters nationwide 61,843,750 by Total Number of Clustered Precincts 85,769 equals 721 average number of voters per clustered precinct.

At a 75 percent turnout rate, there is an average 541 votes per ER. If there are still 1,930 untransmitted ERs with 541 votes per ER, the unreported votes total 1,043,721.

"Untransmitted ERs are a perennial problem in the country’s Automated Election System (AES)," Namfrel said.

In the past elections, the failed transmission rates were 9.5 percent of 76,528 election returns in 2010, 24 percent of 78,193 election returns in 2013, and 3.5 percent of 92,506 election returns in 2016.

"Comelec has repeatedly stated that these missing ERs were eventually “aggregated” in the final count although the process of aggregation was not opened to the public," Namfrel said.

"In this election however, not only should the 2.25 percent untransmitted rate be reduced to the lowest level possible, but Comelec should also open the aggregation procedure to the political parties, election monitoring bodies and to the general public. Every vote counts," it added. (SunStar Philippines from PR)


SunStar website welcomes friendly debate, but comments posted on this site do not necessarily reflect the views of the SunStar management and its affiliates. SunStar reserves the right to delete, reproduce or modify comments posted here without notice. Posts that are inappropriate will automatically be deleted.

Forum rules:

Do not use obscenity. Some words have been banned. Stick to the topic. Do not veer away from the discussion. Be coherent. Do not shout or use CAPITAL LETTERS!